0700 305 140 Mon–Fri 09–18
Practical guides

The stages of a civil trial

· in category Practical guides

The stages of a civil trial

A civil trial looks like a maze, but it follows an order set by the Code of Civil Procedure. If you know which stage you are in, it is easier to understand why certain documents are requested of you and why some hearings seem to bring nothing new.

1. The written stage

The trial starts with the statement of claim: who is suing whom, what they are asking for, on what grounds and with what evidence. The court filing fee is paid along with it. The court first checks whether the claim is complete and, if anything is missing, asks the plaintiff to complete it within a set time limit.

The claim is then served on the defendant, who responds with a statement of defense: stating their position, raising any defenses and proposing their evidence. The plaintiff may in turn reply to the statement of defense. Only after this exchange of documents is the first hearing date set.

2. The evidence

At the first hearings, the court clarifies what is in dispute and what evidence is useful: documents, witnesses, examination of the parties, expert reports. Evidence is proposed, as a rule, in the statement of claim and in the statement of defense; evidence proposed later may be rejected. That is why the first documents of the trial are written carefully, not in a hurry.

The evidence stage is usually the longest. An expert report, for example, has its own schedule: the expert studies the documents, sometimes visits the site, then files the report, and the parties may challenge it.

3. Closing arguments and the ruling

Once the evidence has been taken, the parties present their closing arguments: each shows why the evidence supports their position. The court may deliver the ruling on the spot or, more often, postpone it for a few days. The ruling is written up and communicated to the parties, and the time limit for challenging it usually runs from that communication.

4. Appeals

The dissatisfied party may file an appeal, and the higher court retries the case on both the facts and the law. In certain cases there is also a second appeal, which concerns only the correct application of the law, not a reassessment of the facts. Not every ruling can be challenged by both; we will tell you in good time which remedy is available in your case.

What you do in the meantime

Keep all the documents you receive and respond quickly when your lawyer asks you for a document or a witness's name. If you are represented, you do not need to attend every hearing, except those at which the court summons you in person, for example for examination.

Also consider the costs: in addition to the fee, there may be the court filing fee and the fees of the expert or the translator. The losing party may be ordered, upon request, to pay the other party's legal costs. We explain each stage to you and represent you at every hearing; see our civil litigation services.

Call Ask for a consultation
WebIDexample